Skip to Content

3 Resume Myths: Keywords, ATS Formatting, and the One-Page Rule

October 15, 2026 by
3 Resume Myths: Keywords, ATS Formatting, and the One-Page Rule
Matt Luensmann
| No comments yet

The three most repeated resume rules (stuff it with keywords, avoid formatting the ATS can't read, keep it to one page) all miss what actually decides whether a resume works: the six-second human scan. At MJL Recruiting & Consulting we tell candidates to write every bullet around a specific outcome, and the keyword, formatting, and length questions mostly answer themselves.

Three of the most repeated pieces of resume advice are: stuff it with keywords, avoid any formatting the ATS can't read, and keep it to one page. All three have a grain of truth. All three pull your attention away from what actually decides whether your resume works.

I took these on across four LinkedIn posts in September and October. This post brings them together, because they share one fix: write for the person who reads your resume, and the system mostly takes care of itself.

Should you stuff your resume with keywords?

No. "Just load your resume with keywords to beat the bots" is some of the most repeated, and most overrated, job search advice out there.

Keyword matching is real. When a recruiter searches an applicant tracking system, resumes that contain the words they searched for show up. But most systems aren't sophisticated enough to reward keyword density, and the ones that are will often treat unnatural repetition as noise. Meanwhile, a resume stuffed with disconnected buzzwords reads terribly to the human who opens it, and a human makes the real decision.

What to do instead: make sure the words that matter for the role genuinely appear because you have that experience, described clearly. If a job requires "contract negotiation" and you've done it, say it in those words. Don't invent language you can't back up in an interview.

Will resume formatting get you rejected by the ATS?

Usually not. "Don't use tables, columns or graphics; the ATS can't read them." You've probably heard some version of this. It's outdated more often than it's true.

Older, rigid parsing systems did struggle with complex layouts. Most modern platforms handle standard formatting, including columns and basic tables, reasonably well. Where formatting genuinely causes problems:

  • Text embedded in images.
  • Unusual fonts that don't parse cleanly.
  • Layouts so creative that critical information ends up in the wrong field.

What to do instead: aim for clarity, not minimalism for its own sake. A clean layout with clear headings and readable fonts works for the system and the person.

Does a resume have to be one page?

No. "One page or two?" is one of the most common questions I get, and it's the wrong question to spend energy on.

Length matters far less than whether the first few lines under each role tell a recruiter what changed because you were there. A two-page resume full of specific, outcome-driven bullets will outperform a one-page resume of generic responsibilities. A tight one-pager with only the sharpest points will outperform a padded two-pager just as easily. The page count was never the variable that mattered.

What do recruiters look for in the six-second resume scan?

Once your resume clears the automated filters, a real person looks at it, usually for six to ten seconds on the first pass. They're not reading line by line. They're scanning for:

  • A clear, recognizable job title.
  • Dates that make sense, without obvious unexplained gaps.
  • Quantified impact: numbers, outcomes and scale over vague responsibility statements.
  • Relevance signals that map to what they're hiring for, positioned near the top where a quick pass will catch them.

In that scan, the reader decides whether to slow down and read the rest. Write for the six-second scan first. The details can hold up under a longer read once you've earned it.

How do you write a strong resume bullet?

Here's the one test I give candidates. Pick any bullet and ask: "Would this be true of literally anyone else who held this title?"

If yes, it isn't doing any work for you. Rewrite it around a specific outcome:

  • Before: "Responsible for managing vendor relationships."
  • After: "Renegotiated contracts with our three largest vendors, cutting annual costs by 14%."
  • Before: "Handled customer support tickets."
  • After: "Cut average ticket resolution time from three days to one by building a triage process for the team of six."

Do that for every bullet and the keyword question, the formatting question and the length question mostly answer themselves. The right words show up because you're describing real work. The layout stays clean because there's no filler to hide. And the length becomes whatever it takes to say what you did.

Frequently asked questions about resume myths

Should I add more keywords to my resume? MJL Recruiting & Consulting recommends against keyword stuffing. Most applicant tracking systems don't reward keyword density, and a human makes the real decision. Use the words that matter for the role where you genuinely have that experience.

Can an ATS read columns and tables? Most modern applicant tracking systems handle standard formatting, including columns and basic tables, reasonably well. MJL Recruiting & Consulting sees real problems mainly with text in images, unusual fonts, and overly creative layouts.

Should my resume be one page or two? MJL Recruiting & Consulting finds page count matters far less than content. A two-page resume of specific, outcome-driven bullets beats a one-page list of generic responsibilities, and a tight one-pager beats a padded two-pager.

How long do recruiters spend looking at a resume? MJL Recruiting & Consulting sees recruiters spend about six to ten seconds on the first pass. They scan for a clear job title, dates that make sense, quantified impact, and relevance signals near the top.

What makes a good resume bullet point? MJL Recruiting & Consulting uses one test: would this bullet be true of anyone else who held the same title? If so, rewrite it around a specific, measurable outcome, like cutting costs by a percentage or reducing resolution time.

If you'd like a second set of eyes on your resume, reach out here.

Sign in to leave a comment
Why Your Seven-Step Interview Process Is Losing Top Candidates