Skip to Content

Reference Checks That Actually Tell You Something (Plus the Questions to Ask)

October 22, 2026 by
Reference Checks That Actually Tell You Something (Plus the Questions to Ask)
Matt Luensmann
| No comments yet

A useful reference check is a structured, roughly 20-minute phone call with at least three people who directly managed the candidate, using the same core questions for each and done before the final decision. At MJL Recruiting & Consulting we treat references as one of the cheapest and most predictive steps in hiring, not a formality after the offer is drafted.

By the time most companies get to references, the decision is already made. The call becomes a formality: confirm the dates, confirm the title, ask if they'd hire the person again, hang up.

That version of a reference check almost never changes the outcome, which is why so many owners have decided references are useless. They're not useless. They're usually just done badly.

I wrote about this on LinkedIn in October, and it connects to a September post on the cost of rushing a hire. This is the fuller version, with the questions I actually use.

Are reference checks worth doing?

Yes, when they're done well. A reference check is one of the few chances you get to hear about a candidate from someone who watched them work day to day. Your interviews show you how someone presents. References show you how they performed.

The evidence backs this up. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management notes that reference checks predict job performance better than years of education or experience, and recommends structured phone checks of about 20 minutes each, with at least three contacts and consistent questions.

Compare that to what a bad hire costs. In a CareerBuilder survey from 2017, 74% of employers said they'd hired the wrong person, and the average bad hire cost $14,900. That's before counting the time to search again and the strain on the team in the meantime. An hour of phone calls is cheap insurance.

How do you do a good reference check?

Five things make references worth the time:

  1. Talk to people who managed them. Ask for references who supervised the candidate directly, not just peers or friends. A manager has seen them under pressure, given them feedback and watched what they did with it.
  2. Ask every reference the same core questions. Consistency lets you compare answers across references and across candidates. Without it, you're collecting anecdotes.
  3. Ask about specifics from the interview. If the candidate said they led a migration project, ask: "She mentioned she led the migration project. What was her role in how that went?" This is where you find out whether the story holds up.
  4. Ask what kind of manager helped them do their best work. It tells you as much about fit as anything on the resume, and the answer will help whoever manages them next.
  5. Listen for what's missing. Hesitation, faint praise and conspicuous gaps tell you more than a glowing generic answer. "He was always on time" is not an endorsement of someone you're hiring to lead a team.

What questions should you ask a reference?

  • How did you work with this person, and for how long?
  • What were they responsible for, and what did they do especially well?
  • Tell me about a time they had to handle something difficult. What happened?
  • Where did they need the most support or development?
  • What kind of manager or environment brought out their best work?
  • They told us about [specific project or result]. What was their part in it?
  • If you had the right role open, would you hire them again? What would that role be?

The last question is useful because of the second half. Someone who would hire the candidate again "for the right role" may be telling you what the right role is, and whether yours is it.

When should you check references?

Do references before the final decision, not after. If they're only a formality once the offer is drafted, you've already decided not to listen to them.

Two or three structured conversations, about twenty minutes each. That's the investment. Compared to the cost of a hire that doesn't work out, it's one of the cheapest steps in the entire process.

If you'd like a reference check template built around your must-haves, reach out through the contact page.

Frequently asked questions about reference checks

Do reference checks predict job performance? Yes. MJL Recruiting & Consulting points to the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, which notes that reference checks predict job performance better than years of education or experience when they're structured and consistent.

How many references should you check? MJL Recruiting & Consulting recommends at least two or three structured phone conversations of about 20 minutes each, ideally with people who directly managed the candidate. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management recommends at least three contacts.

What is the best question to ask a reference? MJL Recruiting & Consulting's favorite is: "If you had the right role open, would you hire them again? What would that role be?" The second half often tells you what role the candidate is truly best suited for.

When should reference checks happen in the hiring process? MJL Recruiting & Consulting recommends checking references before the final decision, not after the offer is drafted. If references are only a formality, you've already decided not to listen to them.

How much does a bad hire cost? In a 2017 CareerBuilder survey cited by MJL Recruiting & Consulting, 74% of employers said they'd hired the wrong person, and the average bad hire cost $14,900, before counting the time to search again.

If you're struggling to do reference checks worth doing, we'd love to assist!

Sources:


Sign in to leave a comment
The Hiring Market Has Changed. Has Your Strategy?